World Shia Forum

Identity, Equality, Unity

Shia Muslims: Indonesian villages burned down

indonesian-shia-3Editors note: we are posting the news and link to a BBC report on persecution of Shia in Indonesia. This is followed by an independent analysis, explaining why this is happening in traditionally peaceful and progressive nations like Indonesia and Malaysia.

Exactly four months ago, a mob of Indonesian Sunni Muslims clashed with a group of Shias in their village of Madura, in East Java.

The Shias have been branded a deviant sect by the Islamic authorities in the area and their houses were burned down, with one person killed.

Indonesia is the world’s most populous Muslim nation but the majority of the country’s Muslims are Sunnis.

Being a Shia is not illegal in Indonesia, but religious minorities have complained that they are increasingly becoming the victims of violent crimes that often go unpunished.

Karishma Vaswani reports from Madura.

December 6, 2012

Indonesia’s Shi’a minority is under heavy attack. Men, women, and children have been assaulted, schools damaged, and villages burned to the ground. Many have been killed. It is becoming increasingly clear that Saudi Arabia’s intolerant brand of Wahhabi Sunni Islam—propagated farand wide by Saudi oil money—is behind most of assaults.

Naila Zakiyah, a lecturer at a Shi’a school for girls in the city of Bangil, East Java, recently explained to us:

“In light of recent events, we are naturally worried about the safety of our students… We feel discriminated against. Before this year’s Ramadan, the Sunni mosque across the street broadcasted their sermon twice a week. They had their loudspeakers directed towards our school. They were shouting that Shi’a teaching is misguided, and that spilling our blood ishalal. It is said that those who are attacking us are being funded by money from Saudi Arabia. In 2007, for example, 500 people demonstrated in front of our boarding school; the Saudis gave each person $2.”

When we visited the neighboring mosque, our hosts showed us anti-Shi’a pamphlets and said that they couldn’t talk to their Shi’a neighbors “in a subtle way anymore.” They added, “If they don’t want to convert, then we have to use violence. In our opinion, they are kafir. We will not be at peace with them until we die, even if our lives are at stake. They have already insulted Islam! If the police do not take action against the Shi’a, we will resort to violence.”

And violence they use.

In late December 2011, a mob of over 500 Sunnis drove 300 Shiites from their houses in the village of Nangkernang, Madura Island. Countless dwellings, including a boarding school and a place of worship, were destroyed.

As is common in Indonesia, local authorities sided with the attackers. Only one person was charged for the attack on the village and sentenced to a symbolic three months in prison. Around the same time, local Shi’a religious leader Tajul Muluk was charged with blasphemy and sentenced to two years in prison, despite repeated protests from Amnesty International and other international human rights organizations.

After the attack, some villagers cautiously returned, only to face even more devastating terror few months later.

On August 26, 2012 around 30 Shi’ites were traveling from Nangkernang village when they were accosted by a Sunni mob armed with swords and machetes. According to Indonesian press, two people were murdered as they attempted to defend women and children. When we investigated, the villagers told us that only one person had been killed but at least five had been wounded. Moreover, they said, members of the mob had taken some Shi’a children away from their parents. The mob also set fire to several homes, including one belonging to Tajul Muluk.

We visited the village in October, defying an explicit prohibition by the police force stationed in the area. After slipping through the rice fields in the middle of the night, we finally managed to meet representatives of the local Shi’a community.

“Now we are afraid to say or to show that we are Shi’ites,” said one. “Here, two communities are living side by side. Not all attackers came from the outside; some were from our own village.”

After the onslaught, more than 170 people left central Madura for a refugee camp in the city of Sampang.

Even this facility—a converted covered tennis stadium—is out of reach for most independent journalists, and it took great effort to negotiate our entry.

Refugees were clearly in despair. They all wanted to return home, but the government insisted that they would be “relocated” instead. Once again the Indonesian government was more interested in appeasing a cabal of sectarian aggressors than in pushing for justice.

Suryadharma Ali, Indonesia’s minister of religious affairs, has left little doubt about his sympathies. “Converting Shiite Muslims to the Sunni Islam followed by most Indonesians,” he declared, “would be the best way to prevent violent outbreaks.”

The Essence Of Domination

At the end of November, the desperate, disheartened, and hungry refugees in Sampang sent an envoy to the Indonesian House of Representatives.

They demanded that they be allowed to return home. They had their back against the wall, as the local government had announced it would stop supplying them with food and water.

Instead of sympathy and support, the envoy had insults thrown in his face. According to theJakarta Post, one lawmaker “indulged in ethnic stereotyping, attributing the violence that befell the Shia to their heritage as coarse Maduran fishermen,” adding that Indonesia’s Shi’ites “must learn to adapt to the norm.” Another legislator expressed his suspicion that “the Shiites had created their own problems themselves.”

We contacted our colleagues from the NGO Kontras, which deals with displaced and disappeared Indonesians, and asked them for a comment.

“It is very sad to see that only a few legislators attended the meeting. I am afraid that they are not serious in defending the minorities here,” said Kontras coordinator Haris Azhar. “In my opinion, the essence of domination is when the fate of minorities is determined by the majority. They forget that there are rights that can’t be contested.”

The same day we called the camp in Sampang and spoke to one of our contacts there, Nur Kholis. He sounded depressed. “We feel betrayed,” he said. “The government still wants to relocate us – move us somewhere where we don’t belong. We just want to go home.”

Collusion Across The Seas

This is the latest chapter of gross discrimination against minorities in Indonesia.

Since 1965, Indonesian authorities have committed at least three massacres that could be considered genocides. Between 1 and 3 million people—mainly leftists and members of the country’s Chinese minority—died during and after the 1965 military coup. Indonesian forces also killed or starved around 30 percent of inhabitants of East Timor. And at least 120,000 people have been killed in Papua in a conflict that continues to fester.

Discrimination against Indonesia’s many ethnic and religious minorities did not end after Suharto stepped down in 1998. Since then, there have been brutal and often deadly attacks against “liberal” Muslims, Muslims from the Ahmadiyah sect, and of course against Shi’ites. There have been countless other attacks against Christians, members of indigenous traditions, and more recently Hindus as well.

Are these latest attacks homegrown? That is highly doubtful. Indonesian decision makers since 1965—military, economical, political, and religious—have long been known to collaborate with foreign powers and interests.  The attacks against Shi’ites and other religious minorities in Indonesia mirror those happening in Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, and other parts of the Muslim world closely allied to the West.

“There are many madrassas in Indonesia that have been funded by money from Saudi Arabia,” says Ali Fauzi, a younger brother of one of the terrorists responsible for the bombing in on Bali in 2002. “In exchange they are expected to promote the Saudi brand of Islam – Wahhabism. They are expected to oppose Shi’a belief and even to attack Shi’ites, as the message coming from Saudi Arabia is that Shi’a teaching is heretical.”

Andre Vltchek is a novelist, filmmaker, and investigative journalist. He covered wars and conflicts in dozens of countries. His book on Western imperialism in South Pacific is called Oceania. His provocative book about post-Suharto Indonesia and the market-fundamentalist model is called Indonesia – The Archipelago of Fear (Pluto). After living for many years in Latin America and Oceania, Vltchek presently resides and works in East Asia and Africa. He can be reached through his website.

Rossie Indira is an independent writer, architect, and consultant. Her latest book Surat Dari Bude Ocie is about her travels to Latin American countries. With Andre Vltchek, she cowrote Exile, a book of conversations with Pramoedya Ananta Toer. She was the production manager and translator of the documentary film Terlena–Breaking of a Nation. Rossie lives in Indonesia and can be reached through her website.


Further Reading:


About alitaj

5 comments on “Shia Muslims: Indonesian villages burned down

  1. Sohail Khurshid
    December 28, 2012

    One can find a very similar news report on Indonesian Ahmadis being persecuted by sunnis dating some years back when similar riots arose in a village and a mob of sunnis brutally killed some Ahmadis chanting ‘AllahuAkbar’! The government evacuated them from their native village and forced them to live in a similar refugee camp on some island with the same excuse i.e. ‘they would be safer this way’.

    Now Shi’ites should’ve realized how big was their mistake to support the Sunnis when declaring Ahmadis as heretics back in 1974, it’s really sad but a hard fact.

  2. Pingback: A Sipah e Sahaba leader speaks | Brown Pundits

  3. ALI....ATHAR
    January 1, 2013


  4. Pingback: Shia Genocide..and a word about native informants | Brown Pundits

  5. Dr. Mazhar Naqvi
    June 23, 2015

    very shameful act..beshumar lanat on the peoples involved in such disgusting activities.

    Dr. Mazhar Naqvi

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on December 28, 2012 by in WSF and tagged , , , , , , .
%d bloggers like this: